Gibson J-45 vs Martin D-18 Acoustic Guitar Comparison

The Martin D-18 and Gibson J-45 are two of the most iconic dreadnoughts on the market. They both mahogany back and sides and spruce tops, but there are some key differences between them.

I’ll be comparing the specifications and tones of both these guitars in as much detail as possible so you can decide which is the best acoustic guitar for you.

The Key Differences

The Martin D-18 is a square-shoulder dreadnought with a 25.4″ scale whereas the Gibson J-45 is a sloped-shoulder dreadnought with a 24.75″ scale. The D-18 sounds more articulate and louder compared to the J-45 which sounds darker and mellower. Both guitars have a spruce top and mahogany back and sides.

FeatureMartin D-18Gibson J-45 Standard
ShapeSquare-Shoulder DreadnoughtSloped-Shoulder Dreadnought
Fingerboard Radius16”12”
Nut Width1.75”1.72”
Neck ShapeModified Low OvalSlim Taper
Neck FinishSatinGloss
Color OptionsNaturalVintage Sunburst or Cherry
Differences between the Martin D-18 and Gibson J-45 acoustic guitars

Martin D-18

Gibson J-45

Images link to Amazon

Tone Comparison

Both guitars have X-bracing, mahogany back and sides and spruce tops and hence sound similar, but they don’t sound the same.

There are two reasons for this:

  • The D-18 has a longer scale length
  • The D-18 has square shoulders and the J-45 has round shoulders

The D-18 sounds louder and more articulate compared to the J-45 which has a darker tone. The D-18 is most associated with flat-picking and bluegrass style music, whereas the J-45 is often used by singer-songwriters as it sits back in the mix more.

If you are playing as a soloist then the D-18 will really shine, whereas if you need something that sounds a little more relaxed for strumming then the J-45 will do a great job.

You can’t really go wrong with either of these guitars. Both sound great, they just sound a little bit different.

It’s worth noting here that no two D-18’s or J-45’s sound exactly the same. That’s why I’d always recommend trying the guitars out in the store before you purchase anything because some really do sound better than others.

Check out this video to hear a D-18 and J-45 being played back-to-back.

Feel and Playability

There are three differences to unpack here:

  • Body shape
  • Neck design
  • Scale length

Let’s take a look at each aspect individually.

Body Shape

Although both guitars are dreadnoughts, the D-18 has square shoulders whereas the J-45 has sloped shoulders. Both have a similar overall size, however the J-45 does have a slightly larger lower bout and waist, and is a touch longer than the D-18.

Here are the dimensions.

DimensionMartin D-18Gibson J-45
Upper Bout Width11.5″11.4″
Lower Bout Width15.6”16”
Body Length20”20.25”
Body Depth (Lower Bout)4.8”4.8”

Neck Design

There are several main differences between the neck designs on these two guitars:

  • Both guitars have a C-shape neck but the J-45’s is a bit thicker compared to the D-18’s.
  • The D-18 has a 16″ fretboard radius whereas the J-45 has a 12″ radius. This means the fretboard feels flatter on the D-18 which suits string bending but can make chords more difficult.
  • The D-18 has a slightly wider fretboard compared to the J-45. The D-18’s nut width is 1.75″ whereas the J-45’s is 1.72″.
  • The D-18 has a satin neck finish which feels faster compared to the gloss finish on the J-45.

I strongly recommend trying these two guitars in a store back to back so you can really feel which has the most comfortable neck for you as it is very subjective.

Scale Length

The J-45 has a 24.75″ scale length whereas the D-18 has a 25.4″ scale length. This impacts the fret spacing and string tension.

Since both guitars have 20 frets, they are spaced further apart on the D-18 due to the longer scale length. This can make chording more difficult if you have smaller fingers, but some players prefer the wider spacing. Again, it’s personal preference here.

The Martin D-18 has a longer scale length and slightly thicker stock strings which means they are under more tension. This can make it tougher to bend and fret the strings on the D-18 compared to on the J-45.

However, an advantage of the extra tension is that it allows you to get a lower action without causing fret buzz so it’s not always as difficult to use.

Cosmetic Differences

The Martin D-18 has a natural finish where you can see the color of the wood underneath the gloss, whereas the J-45 Standard comes in either a vintage sunburst or cherry finish which gives it a bolder appearance.

Other purely cosmetic differences between these guitars include:

  • The J-45 has either a black or tortoise pickguard whereas the D-18 has a tortoise pickguard
  • The J-45 has a single-stripe rosette whereas the D-18 has a multi-stripe rosette
  • The J-45 has mother of pearl dot inlays whereas the D-18 has abalone dot inlays
  • The J-45 has white body binding whereas the D-18 has tortoise binding

Martin D-18

Gibson J-45

Images link to Amazon


  • Spruce top and mahogany back, sides and neck
  • Scalloped X-bracing pattern
  • 20 frets
  • Hard-shell case included
  • Left-handed versions available

Comparing Specifications

Here is a table comparing the specifications of these two guitars in detail.

If you want to check the current prices of each model, here are links to Guitar Center:

FeatureMartin D-28Gibson J-45 Standard
ShapeSquare-Shoulder DreadnoughtSloped-Shoulder Dreadnought
Body Width (Max)15.6”16”
Body Length20”20.25”
Body Depth4.8”4.8”
Body FinishGlossGloss
Bracing PatternForward-Shifted X-BracingTraditional X-bracing
Scalloped BracingYesYes
TopSolid Sitka SpruceSolid Sitka Spruce
Back and SidesSolid MahoganySolid Mahogany
Fingerboard Radius16”12”
Nut Width1.75”1.72”
Neck ShapeModified Low Oval High Performance TaperSlim Taper
Neck FinishSatinGloss
PickupFishman (Various)/ LR Baggs AnthemLR Baggs VTC
BridgeModern BellyBelly Up
SaddleCompensated BoneTusq
BindingFaux TortoiseWhite
PickguardTortoise TraditionalBlack Teardrop/ Tortoise Teardrop
InlaysAbalone DotsMother of Pearl Dots
Tuning MachinesNickel Open GearNickel Grover Rotomatics
Left-Hand AvailableYesYes
Color OptionsNaturalVintage Sunburst or Cherry

Here are some more articles you might find useful:


Hey, I'm Heather. I started playing an electric guitar when I was given a Squier Strat for my birthday around 15 years ago. I now own an acoustic guitar and several electric guitars including my personal favourite, a PRS SE Custom 24.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts